By Tom Moran | Star-Ledger Editorial Board
Email the author | Follow on Twitter
on April 26, 2015 at 8:00 AM, updated April 26, 2015 at 10:05 AM
If Gov. Chris Christie didn't lie so much, I might be tempted to feel sorry for him these days.
But he tells such whoppers.
In his latest swing through New Hampshire, he repeated his claim that New Jersey has the highest taxes in the country. We rank No. 7 in combined state and local taxes per person, and No. 10 as a share of income.
And he was only clearing his throat with that one. On Thursday, he told voters at a town hall meeting in Cedar Grove that Democrats are the ones who shorted the pension fund.
"The Legislature passed it, and I signed it, with that number in it," he said.
Scary. Because this is not a small point; it is at the core of the pension case now before the state Supreme Court.
The truth is that Democrats passed a budget with the full pension payment, to prove it could be done. Christie removed that money with his line-item veto. Did he really forget that?
Here's why we should all care: New Jersey's budget crisis is the second worst in the nation, behind Illinois'. But instead of looking for common ground with Democrats, the governor is taking reckless pot shots and refusing to budge.
Senate President Stephen Sweeney, the governor's lead Democratic partner in his first term, says the bromance that made the 2011 reform possible is now dead.
"It's night and day," says Sweeney (D-Gloucester). "In 2011 we did things face to face, a lot of discussion. Now he attacks me on Twitter."
If you want to dig for the roots of this standoff, start with Christie's presidential campaign.
That ties his hands. He can't do anything to offend Republican base voters, like sign a small tax hike on incomes over $1 million.
Democratic leaders vow they will not cut a deal that puts the entire burden on public workers, as Christie has proposed.
A bump in the "millionaires tax" would not come close to solving the fiscal problem, but it would soften the need for cuts a bit, and help party leaders sell the deal to fellow Democrats.
"At the end of the day everyone has to be realistic," says Assembly Speaker Vincent Prieto (D-Hudson).
This is where the poison left by Christie's broken promise does such damage. The 2011 reform was a bargain: Public workers had to pay more into the system and take less out. They did their part.
The governor agreed to ramp up pension payments in return. But his "Jersey Comeback" never materialized, so he broke that promise and shorted the funds.
This time around, Democrats and their union allies are in a sour mood. They feel burned.
Sweeney and Prieto both joined the union lawsuit that seeks to force full pension payments on the 2011 schedule. But they both know that would be almost impossible. It would require $3.1 billion next year, and as much as $5 billion two years later.
In interviews, both Sweeney and Prieto say they will present a budget this year that includes full payments, but would settle for less if a fair political deal could be reached.
"We may need to spread the payments out over a longer period of time," Prieto says. "But we should be making a good-faith effort to honor what we are supposed to be doing."
The wild card is the Supreme Court, which hears the case in two weeks. The key question is whether the 2011 law amounts to a contract that must be honored, and the smart money says the unions are likely to win again, as they did in lower courts.
But what then? The court has no means to enforce its ruling. And Christie will be sorely tempted to go rogue and defy the ruling if he loses. Attacking a liberal court and public worker unions could work magic among the GOP base.
"It's conceivable they would hold the governor in contempt," says professor Robert Williams, an expert on the state constitution at the Rutgers-Camden School of Law. "We could face a constitutional crisis."
Courts try to avoid that by giving the players political wiggle room, as the lower court did. If that happens, the search for political compromise will resume.
And that's where Christie's political campaign is such a curse to this state.
Democrats seem ready to cut that deal if it includes a millionaires tax. And two-thirds of New Jersey voters think it should be included.
But Christie doesn't need our votes anymore. He's competing for the crazy GOP base vote now. And that could be toxic for New Jersey's future.
Tom Moran may be reached at tmoran@starledger.com o
Total Pageviews
Monday, April 27, 2015
Friday, April 24, 2015
N.J. public worker pension fund gap widens to $40B
N.J. public worker pension fund gap widens to $40B
By Samantha Marcus | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com
Email the author | Follow on Twitter
on April 23, 2015 at 5:40 PM, updated April 24, 2015 at 1:04 AM
TRENTON — New Jersey's funding gap for public worker pensions continued to widen last year to $40 billion, adding $4.5 billion in pension debt from 2013.
The unfunded liability, or the difference between the money the state has on hand versus what it would cost to fully fund benefits for future and current retirees, surged as the state slashed planned payments into the system, which ranks among the largest and least healthy in the country.
The pension system was worth about $42.5 billion at the end of the 2014 fiscal year last June, while the price tag to meet those retirement promises was $82.6 billion, according to actuary reports for the state's seven pension funds released this week.
As a result, the ratio of assets to liabilities slid from 55.6 percent to 51.5 percent. Experts generally say a pension fund with an 80 percent funding ratio is considered healthy.
"We were expecting it because the governor has failed to put in for two and now coming up on three payments," said Tom Bruno, chairman of the Public Employees' Retirement System Board of Trustees. "It didn't surprise us."
The pension system has three funding streams, including worker contributions, public employer contributions and investment returns.
Gov. Chris Christie scrubbed $2.4 billion from payments into the fund in 2014 and 2015. And the $1.3 billion proposed payment for the upcoming 2016 fiscal year that Christie hailed as the largest in state history is $1.8 billion less than he was scheduled to pay in and less still than what actuaries recommend.
After Christie slashed the state's payment in 2014, labor unions fought him in court and lost. They won a trial court battle in February to force Christie to restore this year's payment, and the state Supreme Court will hear that case next month.
The unfunded liability has been climbing since the turn of the 21st century largely because of investment losses, increased benefits and chronic underfunding. In a National Association of State Retirement Administrators's study of states' contribution from 2001 to 2013, New Jersey had the worst record.
Within the pension system there are seven individual pension funds for police and firefighters, teachers, judges and other public employees. Two of the largest funds — the Teachers' Pension and Annuity Fund and the Public Employees' Retirement System — are on pace to run out of money within 12 years.
Scott Porter, a Milliman actuary, told the trustees of the teachers' fund on Wednesday that he's concerned about "the ongoing solvency of the fund," which could be depleted by 2027.
In the world of pension funding, he said, "that is very, very close. It's tomorrow."
The state portion of the Public Employees' Retirement System, which trails the teachers as the second largest pension fund, is just 43.8 percent funded, down from 48.1 percent in 2013. Meanwhile, the portion of those liabilities covered by municipalities, is 73.5 percent funded.
The Police and Firemen's Retirement System is also largely funded by local governments, and that chunk is 76.3 percent funded, while the state's smaller end is 47.2 percent funded.
The fund is stable "in spite of" the state underfunding the system, said Patrick Colligan, president of the New Jersey State Policemen's Benevolent Association.
"Our members are out there everyday working for our communities and continuing to make the payments required to make sure members and their families have a stable pension fund for their retirement, he said. "Today's actuarial report shows quite clearly that it is well past time for Gov. Christie to begin meeting his responsibilities."
A spokesman for the Department of Treasury declined to comment Thursday.
MORE POLITICS
Samantha Marcus may be reached at smarcus@njadvancemedia.com . Follow her on Twitter @samanthamarcus. Find NJ.com Politics on Facebook.
Christie accuses Dems of 'suing themselves' over pension shortfall they created, approved
By Claude Brodesser-Akner | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com
Email the author
on April 23, 2015 at 12:35 PM, updated April 23, 2015 at 4:09 PM
CEDAR GROVE — Gov. Chris Christie on Thursday accused the Democratic leaders of the state Legislature of "suing themselves" after they joined in court papers of public employee unions suing the state to make a full pension payment.
Speaking at a town hall meeting in Cedar Grove, Christie went on the offensive against the NJEA and state Democrats, placing the blame squarely on a Legislature that had accepted and approved a budget with a lower pension payment in the first place.
Christie acknowledged "the payment we made this year was supposed to be $1.6 billion more than it was" but noted that, facing a revenue shortfall, the Democratically-controlled Legislature had approved a final budget that called for a pension payment of a slightly more than $650 million dollars.
MORE: Christie warns parents opting out of PARCC could trigger reduced services, higher local taxes
"They (the NJEA and its supporters in the Legislature) are now suing to force the court to force them to do what they didn't do," Christie said, "They are essentially suing themselves. It's extraordinary."
The reality is a bit more complicated: The New Jersey Legislature earmarked $2.25 billion into the Appropriations Act. However, the governor then used a line item veto to cut a little over $1.5 billion, leaving a pension payment of $677 million in fiscal year 2015.
Instead, Christie argued, the state should institute a three-step reform package that will reduce health benefits from platinum plus to "gold" and reinvest the savings to help shore up the pension system, which would result in $3 billion in savings.
He also argued the creaking pension system's benefits should be frozen and the administration of the payments be removed from the hands of politicians and turned over to the unions.
"We do those steps, we fix this problem," Christie said.
However, the NJ Education Association doesn't see it that way. On Tuesday, it announced it was cutting off talks with the Christie administration over pension reform, and focusing its efforts on getting a payment via the courts.
Christie insisted he would love to make the payment, but warned the assembled crowd of 200 in the gym of Essex County College's Public Safety Academy that there was no "money tree" that would magically make up the short fall.
"Here's the problem," said Christie, "You're the money tree. They're Robin Hood, alright: They're gonna take it from you, and give it to them."
Christie added the alternatives were too harsh to bear: Revenue increases in either the sales or income tax would need to occur, stifling growth and jobs. To make up the shortfall, the sales tax would need to be hiked to 10 percent, or the income tax would need to be raised by 29 percent.
Raising the millionaire's tax further would only provide $500 million of the missing $3.3 billion, Christie said, but he also warned it would come with a side-effect.
"Be careful," he warned, "You know what happened last year? 10,000 millionaires left New Jersey. People of wealth can move, and they can move easily."
Christie noted that many of the well-heeled had decamped to Florida, perhaps permanently.
"Why? Not just the wonderful climate. Zero income tax," he said, "Don't fall for it."
By Samantha Marcus | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com
Email the author | Follow on Twitter
on April 23, 2015 at 5:40 PM, updated April 24, 2015 at 1:04 AM
TRENTON — New Jersey's funding gap for public worker pensions continued to widen last year to $40 billion, adding $4.5 billion in pension debt from 2013.
The unfunded liability, or the difference between the money the state has on hand versus what it would cost to fully fund benefits for future and current retirees, surged as the state slashed planned payments into the system, which ranks among the largest and least healthy in the country.
The pension system was worth about $42.5 billion at the end of the 2014 fiscal year last June, while the price tag to meet those retirement promises was $82.6 billion, according to actuary reports for the state's seven pension funds released this week.
As a result, the ratio of assets to liabilities slid from 55.6 percent to 51.5 percent. Experts generally say a pension fund with an 80 percent funding ratio is considered healthy.
"We were expecting it because the governor has failed to put in for two and now coming up on three payments," said Tom Bruno, chairman of the Public Employees' Retirement System Board of Trustees. "It didn't surprise us."
The pension system has three funding streams, including worker contributions, public employer contributions and investment returns.
Gov. Chris Christie scrubbed $2.4 billion from payments into the fund in 2014 and 2015. And the $1.3 billion proposed payment for the upcoming 2016 fiscal year that Christie hailed as the largest in state history is $1.8 billion less than he was scheduled to pay in and less still than what actuaries recommend.
After Christie slashed the state's payment in 2014, labor unions fought him in court and lost. They won a trial court battle in February to force Christie to restore this year's payment, and the state Supreme Court will hear that case next month.
The unfunded liability has been climbing since the turn of the 21st century largely because of investment losses, increased benefits and chronic underfunding. In a National Association of State Retirement Administrators's study of states' contribution from 2001 to 2013, New Jersey had the worst record.
Within the pension system there are seven individual pension funds for police and firefighters, teachers, judges and other public employees. Two of the largest funds — the Teachers' Pension and Annuity Fund and the Public Employees' Retirement System — are on pace to run out of money within 12 years.
Scott Porter, a Milliman actuary, told the trustees of the teachers' fund on Wednesday that he's concerned about "the ongoing solvency of the fund," which could be depleted by 2027.
In the world of pension funding, he said, "that is very, very close. It's tomorrow."
The state portion of the Public Employees' Retirement System, which trails the teachers as the second largest pension fund, is just 43.8 percent funded, down from 48.1 percent in 2013. Meanwhile, the portion of those liabilities covered by municipalities, is 73.5 percent funded.
The Police and Firemen's Retirement System is also largely funded by local governments, and that chunk is 76.3 percent funded, while the state's smaller end is 47.2 percent funded.
The fund is stable "in spite of" the state underfunding the system, said Patrick Colligan, president of the New Jersey State Policemen's Benevolent Association.
"Our members are out there everyday working for our communities and continuing to make the payments required to make sure members and their families have a stable pension fund for their retirement, he said. "Today's actuarial report shows quite clearly that it is well past time for Gov. Christie to begin meeting his responsibilities."
A spokesman for the Department of Treasury declined to comment Thursday.
MORE POLITICS
Samantha Marcus may be reached at smarcus@njadvancemedia.com . Follow her on Twitter @samanthamarcus. Find NJ.com Politics on Facebook.
Christie accuses Dems of 'suing themselves' over pension shortfall they created, approved
By Claude Brodesser-Akner | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com
Email the author
on April 23, 2015 at 12:35 PM, updated April 23, 2015 at 4:09 PM
CEDAR GROVE — Gov. Chris Christie on Thursday accused the Democratic leaders of the state Legislature of "suing themselves" after they joined in court papers of public employee unions suing the state to make a full pension payment.
Speaking at a town hall meeting in Cedar Grove, Christie went on the offensive against the NJEA and state Democrats, placing the blame squarely on a Legislature that had accepted and approved a budget with a lower pension payment in the first place.
Christie acknowledged "the payment we made this year was supposed to be $1.6 billion more than it was" but noted that, facing a revenue shortfall, the Democratically-controlled Legislature had approved a final budget that called for a pension payment of a slightly more than $650 million dollars.
MORE: Christie warns parents opting out of PARCC could trigger reduced services, higher local taxes
"They (the NJEA and its supporters in the Legislature) are now suing to force the court to force them to do what they didn't do," Christie said, "They are essentially suing themselves. It's extraordinary."
The reality is a bit more complicated: The New Jersey Legislature earmarked $2.25 billion into the Appropriations Act. However, the governor then used a line item veto to cut a little over $1.5 billion, leaving a pension payment of $677 million in fiscal year 2015.
Instead, Christie argued, the state should institute a three-step reform package that will reduce health benefits from platinum plus to "gold" and reinvest the savings to help shore up the pension system, which would result in $3 billion in savings.
He also argued the creaking pension system's benefits should be frozen and the administration of the payments be removed from the hands of politicians and turned over to the unions.
"We do those steps, we fix this problem," Christie said.
However, the NJ Education Association doesn't see it that way. On Tuesday, it announced it was cutting off talks with the Christie administration over pension reform, and focusing its efforts on getting a payment via the courts.
Christie insisted he would love to make the payment, but warned the assembled crowd of 200 in the gym of Essex County College's Public Safety Academy that there was no "money tree" that would magically make up the short fall.
"Here's the problem," said Christie, "You're the money tree. They're Robin Hood, alright: They're gonna take it from you, and give it to them."
Christie added the alternatives were too harsh to bear: Revenue increases in either the sales or income tax would need to occur, stifling growth and jobs. To make up the shortfall, the sales tax would need to be hiked to 10 percent, or the income tax would need to be raised by 29 percent.
Raising the millionaire's tax further would only provide $500 million of the missing $3.3 billion, Christie said, but he also warned it would come with a side-effect.
"Be careful," he warned, "You know what happened last year? 10,000 millionaires left New Jersey. People of wealth can move, and they can move easily."
Christie noted that many of the well-heeled had decamped to Florida, perhaps permanently.
"Why? Not just the wonderful climate. Zero income tax," he said, "Don't fall for it."
Thursday, April 23, 2015
NJ Releases PFRS Actuarial Report; Pension Fund Remains Stable in Spite of State’s Refusal to Meet Obligations
NJ Releases PFRS Actuarial Report; Pension Fund Remains Stable in Spite of State’s Refusal to Meet Obligations
Posted: Wednesday / 4.22.2015 / 1:45 PM
Tags: PFRS
WOODBRIDGE- New Jersey State Policemen’s Benevolent Association President Patrick Colligan today released the following statement on the actuarial report released by the New Jersey Division of Pension and Benefits detailing the fact that the Police and Firemen’s Retirement System (PFRS) continues to be stable with a funding level of 76.9%. This stable funding percentage comes in spite of the fact that the additional 1.5% contribution members are being forced to pay every year is not being used to fund their pensions as mandated in the Chapter 78 legislation of 2011 and is instead being funneled to towns and counties across New Jersey to decrease their required contributions. Chapter 78 increased PFRS members’ pension contribution numbers from 8.5% to 10%, representing the highest contribution of any employee in New Jersey.
The stable funding level is also in spite of the state refusing to meet their mandated funding obligations and flies in the face of Governor Christie’s ongoing efforts to paint the PFRS fund as in crisis. A review by NJSPBA Trustees shows that if the state met their funding obligations and the 1.5% additional contribution were being used to fund the PFRS as the law states rather than being funneled off to towns and counties to fulfill their own pension obligations, the fund would be operating at an even more robust 88% funding level.
“Our members are out there every day working for our communities and continuing to make the payments required to make sure members and their families have a stable pension fund for their retirement. Simply put, they are meeting their responsibilities and abiding by the agreed upon terms from when they first agreed to serve the public. Today’s actuarial report shows quite clearly that it is well past time for Governor Christie to begin meeting his responsibilities.
The PFRS system is stable at almost 77% and the only thing holding it back from operating at an almost 90% funding level is the fact that the governor not only refuses to meet the state’s obligations, but he is also taking the additional 1.5% our members are paying for their pensions and sending it back to towns and counties across New Jersey instead. This funding level would also put us much closer to restoring COLA for our thousands of retired members who have not seen a cost of living adjustment since 2011.
Today’s actuarial report proves what we have long known, Governor Christie and the state’s actions as they relate to the PFRS funding are nothing short of outrageous. Our members are literally having an additional 1.5% syphoned directly from their paychecks as a result of Chapter 78 that is supposed to go towards funding our pension and, instead, the governor is continuing to give it back to the towns and counties. Is it really asking too much to ask for our own money back? Instead of attempting to deceive the public that the PFRS fund is in crisis to try and score public relations points, Governor Christie should acknowledge the fact that our system is stable and would be in even better shape if he stopped shirking his responsibilities. Like the governor, our members don’t consider themselves to be wealthy. The difference is our members actually aren’t.”
Posted: Wednesday / 4.22.2015 / 1:45 PM
Tags: PFRS
WOODBRIDGE- New Jersey State Policemen’s Benevolent Association President Patrick Colligan today released the following statement on the actuarial report released by the New Jersey Division of Pension and Benefits detailing the fact that the Police and Firemen’s Retirement System (PFRS) continues to be stable with a funding level of 76.9%. This stable funding percentage comes in spite of the fact that the additional 1.5% contribution members are being forced to pay every year is not being used to fund their pensions as mandated in the Chapter 78 legislation of 2011 and is instead being funneled to towns and counties across New Jersey to decrease their required contributions. Chapter 78 increased PFRS members’ pension contribution numbers from 8.5% to 10%, representing the highest contribution of any employee in New Jersey.
The stable funding level is also in spite of the state refusing to meet their mandated funding obligations and flies in the face of Governor Christie’s ongoing efforts to paint the PFRS fund as in crisis. A review by NJSPBA Trustees shows that if the state met their funding obligations and the 1.5% additional contribution were being used to fund the PFRS as the law states rather than being funneled off to towns and counties to fulfill their own pension obligations, the fund would be operating at an even more robust 88% funding level.
“Our members are out there every day working for our communities and continuing to make the payments required to make sure members and their families have a stable pension fund for their retirement. Simply put, they are meeting their responsibilities and abiding by the agreed upon terms from when they first agreed to serve the public. Today’s actuarial report shows quite clearly that it is well past time for Governor Christie to begin meeting his responsibilities.
The PFRS system is stable at almost 77% and the only thing holding it back from operating at an almost 90% funding level is the fact that the governor not only refuses to meet the state’s obligations, but he is also taking the additional 1.5% our members are paying for their pensions and sending it back to towns and counties across New Jersey instead. This funding level would also put us much closer to restoring COLA for our thousands of retired members who have not seen a cost of living adjustment since 2011.
Today’s actuarial report proves what we have long known, Governor Christie and the state’s actions as they relate to the PFRS funding are nothing short of outrageous. Our members are literally having an additional 1.5% syphoned directly from their paychecks as a result of Chapter 78 that is supposed to go towards funding our pension and, instead, the governor is continuing to give it back to the towns and counties. Is it really asking too much to ask for our own money back? Instead of attempting to deceive the public that the PFRS fund is in crisis to try and score public relations points, Governor Christie should acknowledge the fact that our system is stable and would be in even better shape if he stopped shirking his responsibilities. Like the governor, our members don’t consider themselves to be wealthy. The difference is our members actually aren’t.”
Sweeney and Prieto to file amicus brief in support of unions in pen/ben battle
Sweeney and Prieto to file amicus brief in support of unions in pen/ben battle
By Chase Brush | 04/20/15 3:58pm
With a second court battle over the state’s failure to put up a full payment into its public pension and benefits system pending, Democratic leaders of the legislature are looking to send the judge presiding over the case a statement that they’re on the side of the plantiffs.
In a amicus brief made public today, Senate President Steve Sweeney (D-3) and Assembly Speaker Vincent Prieto (D-32) announced that they plan to officially inform Superior Court Mary Jacobson of their disapproval of the state’s failure to make the payments, a move that has had Gov. Chris Christie’s administration and public labor unions at loggerheads in recent months. The two first went to court over the issue last year, when Christie decided against making a scheduled payment into the fund for fiscal year 2015.
Christie’s proposed budget for the coming year included another partial payment into the fund, driving public labor organizations — such as the Communication workers of American, the AFL-CIO, and the New Jersey Education Assocation — to file second joint suit against the state for FY2016.
“We want to make it clear to the Court that the administration’s refusal to make the legally required pension payments violates the law and disregards legislative intent,” Sweeney and Prieto said in a joint statement today. “The pension reform bill approved by the Legislature and signed by the governor is a law he can’t choose to ignore. He has a legal, constitutional and contractual obligation to make the required payments.”
Last time around, Jacobson sided with unions in ruling that the state has a constitutional obligation to its public employees under the 2011 pen/ben reform law signed by Christie and the Democratic legislature. Christie has since argued that the state’s shaky fiscal footing requires further reforms to the system, and has proposed a pension overhaul plan that would freeze the state’s current system and create a new one to be possibly managed by unions like the NJEA.
That plan too has been met with criticism, particularly from police and fire unions, who’s funds their representatives argue are largely solvent and in no need of reform.
Supporters of upholding the 2011 law and making the scheduled payments, including Sweeney and Prieto, contend that if the governor had followed the funding timetable as required by the statute, the state be “well on the way to restoring the financial strength of the pension system.”
“The law explicitly creates a contractual obligation to make the contributions,” Sweeney and Prieto said today. “The Legislature met the requirements of the law by appropriating $2.25 billion to make the payment for Fiscal Year 2015. The governor chose to veto the funding and to slash the contribution by $1.57 billion with a line-item veto.
“By appropriating the full payment, the Legislature met the requirements of the State Constitution. The governor can’t veto the constitution,” they added.
The court date over the FY2016 payment is scheduled for May 12, and Sweeney and Prieto said they plan to submit their amicus brief by that time. A Supreme Court hearing on Jacobson’s ruling on the FY2015 payment, which the Christie administration appealed earlier this year, will be held on May 6.
“We support the unions in their lawsuit to force the administration to obey the law. The workers are keeping their part of the agreement with increased contributions, the governor should do the same,” they said. “The continuing refusal by the administration to make the required payments is making the situation worse. The state’s credit rating has been downgraded a record nine times, the state’s fiscal stability has been undermined and members of the pension system are forced to live with the instability of an underfunded plan.”
Unions behind the lawsuit sounded off as well.
“The fact that legislative leaders Sweeney and Prieto are joining the unions’ lawsuit as a friend of the court strengthens our already strong case,” said Charles Wowkanech, president of the New Jersey State AFL-CIO, which represents one million union members and their families. “By committing to the lawsuit, the legislative leaders are demonstrating their belief that the governor must adequately fund the pension system to ensure its long-term viability. A superior court judge and three Wall Street ratings agencies agree.”
By Chase Brush | 04/20/15 3:58pm
With a second court battle over the state’s failure to put up a full payment into its public pension and benefits system pending, Democratic leaders of the legislature are looking to send the judge presiding over the case a statement that they’re on the side of the plantiffs.
In a amicus brief made public today, Senate President Steve Sweeney (D-3) and Assembly Speaker Vincent Prieto (D-32) announced that they plan to officially inform Superior Court Mary Jacobson of their disapproval of the state’s failure to make the payments, a move that has had Gov. Chris Christie’s administration and public labor unions at loggerheads in recent months. The two first went to court over the issue last year, when Christie decided against making a scheduled payment into the fund for fiscal year 2015.
Christie’s proposed budget for the coming year included another partial payment into the fund, driving public labor organizations — such as the Communication workers of American, the AFL-CIO, and the New Jersey Education Assocation — to file second joint suit against the state for FY2016.
“We want to make it clear to the Court that the administration’s refusal to make the legally required pension payments violates the law and disregards legislative intent,” Sweeney and Prieto said in a joint statement today. “The pension reform bill approved by the Legislature and signed by the governor is a law he can’t choose to ignore. He has a legal, constitutional and contractual obligation to make the required payments.”
Last time around, Jacobson sided with unions in ruling that the state has a constitutional obligation to its public employees under the 2011 pen/ben reform law signed by Christie and the Democratic legislature. Christie has since argued that the state’s shaky fiscal footing requires further reforms to the system, and has proposed a pension overhaul plan that would freeze the state’s current system and create a new one to be possibly managed by unions like the NJEA.
That plan too has been met with criticism, particularly from police and fire unions, who’s funds their representatives argue are largely solvent and in no need of reform.
Supporters of upholding the 2011 law and making the scheduled payments, including Sweeney and Prieto, contend that if the governor had followed the funding timetable as required by the statute, the state be “well on the way to restoring the financial strength of the pension system.”
“The law explicitly creates a contractual obligation to make the contributions,” Sweeney and Prieto said today. “The Legislature met the requirements of the law by appropriating $2.25 billion to make the payment for Fiscal Year 2015. The governor chose to veto the funding and to slash the contribution by $1.57 billion with a line-item veto.
“By appropriating the full payment, the Legislature met the requirements of the State Constitution. The governor can’t veto the constitution,” they added.
The court date over the FY2016 payment is scheduled for May 12, and Sweeney and Prieto said they plan to submit their amicus brief by that time. A Supreme Court hearing on Jacobson’s ruling on the FY2015 payment, which the Christie administration appealed earlier this year, will be held on May 6.
“We support the unions in their lawsuit to force the administration to obey the law. The workers are keeping their part of the agreement with increased contributions, the governor should do the same,” they said. “The continuing refusal by the administration to make the required payments is making the situation worse. The state’s credit rating has been downgraded a record nine times, the state’s fiscal stability has been undermined and members of the pension system are forced to live with the instability of an underfunded plan.”
Unions behind the lawsuit sounded off as well.
“The fact that legislative leaders Sweeney and Prieto are joining the unions’ lawsuit as a friend of the court strengthens our already strong case,” said Charles Wowkanech, president of the New Jersey State AFL-CIO, which represents one million union members and their families. “By committing to the lawsuit, the legislative leaders are demonstrating their belief that the governor must adequately fund the pension system to ensure its long-term viability. A superior court judge and three Wall Street ratings agencies agree.”
Wednesday, August 27, 2014
Christie ships pension funds to Wall Street pals, and therein lies a story
Chris Christie's stump speech always includes a passage about how the tough choices had made with regard to pensions, but those choices deserve some healthy scrutiny (Andre Malok/Star-Ledger)
Star-Ledger
on August 27, 2014
There is a curiously overlooked story from David Sirota that examines the mutually profitable kinship between Gov. Chris Christie and Wall Street hedge funds, and the most curious part is that some of them receive an extraordinary amount of New Jersey business – specifically, the stewardship of state pension funds -- after being identified as the guys who bankrolled the political career of Christie himself.
Among the findings that might make your head explode:
1. There has been a 300-percent spike in management fees over the last three years. Somehow, that seems a bit high, but then, he’s a man who likes to pay for premium services.
2. We spent $400 million last year alone to manage these funds – and the funds' 15.9-percent returns are well below the 17.4 national average, according to an analysis firm.
3. Some funds are managed by Elliott Associates, which is run by uber-vulture Paul Singer -- a Christie sugar daddy that you should know, because he’s the kind of guy who can bring entire governments to their knees. Yes, that includes our own.
One paragraph for your perusal:
The state has sent more pension money to big-name Wall Street firms like Blackstone, Third Point, Omega Advisors, Elliott Associates and Grady's old firm, The Carlyle Group. Additionally, the amount of fees the state pays financial managers has more than tripled since Christie assumed office. New Jersey is now one of America's largest investors in hedge funds. The "maximized returns" have yet to materialize. Between fiscal year 2011 and 2014, the state's pension trailed the median returns for similarly sized public pension systems throughout the country, according to data from the financial analysis firm, Wilshire Associates. That below-median performance has cost New Jersey taxpayers billions in unrealized gains and has left the pension system on shaky ground. Meanwhile, New Jersey is now paying a quarter-billion dollars in additional annual fees to Wall Street firms -- many of whose employees have financially supported Republican groups backing Christie's reelection campaign.
There are a few questions that need to be answered here, starting with this one:
Does this story deserve more traction, or have we grown so anesthetized by our leaders taking gargantuan risks with our money to benefit his political cronies?
That's not a rhetorical question.
Star-Ledger
on August 27, 2014
There is a curiously overlooked story from David Sirota that examines the mutually profitable kinship between Gov. Chris Christie and Wall Street hedge funds, and the most curious part is that some of them receive an extraordinary amount of New Jersey business – specifically, the stewardship of state pension funds -- after being identified as the guys who bankrolled the political career of Christie himself.
Among the findings that might make your head explode:
1. There has been a 300-percent spike in management fees over the last three years. Somehow, that seems a bit high, but then, he’s a man who likes to pay for premium services.
2. We spent $400 million last year alone to manage these funds – and the funds' 15.9-percent returns are well below the 17.4 national average, according to an analysis firm.
3. Some funds are managed by Elliott Associates, which is run by uber-vulture Paul Singer -- a Christie sugar daddy that you should know, because he’s the kind of guy who can bring entire governments to their knees. Yes, that includes our own.
One paragraph for your perusal:
The state has sent more pension money to big-name Wall Street firms like Blackstone, Third Point, Omega Advisors, Elliott Associates and Grady's old firm, The Carlyle Group. Additionally, the amount of fees the state pays financial managers has more than tripled since Christie assumed office. New Jersey is now one of America's largest investors in hedge funds. The "maximized returns" have yet to materialize. Between fiscal year 2011 and 2014, the state's pension trailed the median returns for similarly sized public pension systems throughout the country, according to data from the financial analysis firm, Wilshire Associates. That below-median performance has cost New Jersey taxpayers billions in unrealized gains and has left the pension system on shaky ground. Meanwhile, New Jersey is now paying a quarter-billion dollars in additional annual fees to Wall Street firms -- many of whose employees have financially supported Republican groups backing Christie's reelection campaign.
There are a few questions that need to be answered here, starting with this one:
Does this story deserve more traction, or have we grown so anesthetized by our leaders taking gargantuan risks with our money to benefit his political cronies?
That's not a rhetorical question.
Chris Christie's hypocrisy on full display in Illinois
Chris Christie is the man who wasted $12 million on a special election presumes to instruct Illinois on proper poll etiquette.
Star-Ledger
on August 27, 2014
Time once again to hop aboard the traveling hypocrisy circus, governed by the man who never misses an opportunity to employ the same tactics he pretends to deride.
Gov. Christie was in Illinois Tuesday, stumping for some private equity guy running for governor who won’t release his tax returns, and he gave his usual breathtaking show of chutzpah by accusing the sitting governor, Pat Quinn, of manipulating the turnout in November.
“He will try every trick in the book. I see the stuff that’s going on,” said the omnipotent Oz. “Same-day registration all of a sudden this year comes to Illinois. Shocking. I’m sure it was all based upon public policy, good public policy to get same-day registration here in Illinois just this year, when the governor is in the toilet and needs as much help as he can get.”
Just two problems with that. First, it wasn’t the Democrats who got same-day registration passed, it was the Illinois Board of Elections, which consists of four Republicans and four Democrats. And Christie’s candidate, Bruce Rauner, supported it.
Second: Every study shows that same-day registration works superbly in the other 11 states it is used, increasing turnout by 10 percent, eliminating arbitrary deadlines, and facilitating poll access for mobile voters such as college students – while safeguarding against fraud.
"Debilitating stupidity" -- Dick Armey on Chris Christie's 2013 election chicanery
But Christie, now a leader of the party that champions voter suppression, calls same-day registration a maneuver that “would make New Jersey blush.”
Really, that’s precious.
Remember this comes from a governor who knows something about manipulating votes. He spent $12 million in taxpayer funds to hold a special election in October last year and called for a special election so that he wouldn't have to appear on the ballot with Cory Booker in November. He knew that Booker's candidacy would draw out the Democratic base, and he was determined to avoid it, so that he could run up his own margin of victory.
Now, that should make the man blush.
There were a lot of predictable reactions to this shameless hypocrisy, but the most memorable came from the unlikeliest of sources: “Debilitating stupidity," former Republican leader Dick Armey called it on CNN. "Dimwitted."
But that’s voter suppression, and Chris Christie has fully embraced the method. And on Tuesday, he whined about his inability to exercise it.
Star-Ledger
on August 27, 2014
Time once again to hop aboard the traveling hypocrisy circus, governed by the man who never misses an opportunity to employ the same tactics he pretends to deride.
Gov. Christie was in Illinois Tuesday, stumping for some private equity guy running for governor who won’t release his tax returns, and he gave his usual breathtaking show of chutzpah by accusing the sitting governor, Pat Quinn, of manipulating the turnout in November.
“He will try every trick in the book. I see the stuff that’s going on,” said the omnipotent Oz. “Same-day registration all of a sudden this year comes to Illinois. Shocking. I’m sure it was all based upon public policy, good public policy to get same-day registration here in Illinois just this year, when the governor is in the toilet and needs as much help as he can get.”
Just two problems with that. First, it wasn’t the Democrats who got same-day registration passed, it was the Illinois Board of Elections, which consists of four Republicans and four Democrats. And Christie’s candidate, Bruce Rauner, supported it.
Second: Every study shows that same-day registration works superbly in the other 11 states it is used, increasing turnout by 10 percent, eliminating arbitrary deadlines, and facilitating poll access for mobile voters such as college students – while safeguarding against fraud.
"Debilitating stupidity" -- Dick Armey on Chris Christie's 2013 election chicanery
But Christie, now a leader of the party that champions voter suppression, calls same-day registration a maneuver that “would make New Jersey blush.”
Really, that’s precious.
Remember this comes from a governor who knows something about manipulating votes. He spent $12 million in taxpayer funds to hold a special election in October last year and called for a special election so that he wouldn't have to appear on the ballot with Cory Booker in November. He knew that Booker's candidacy would draw out the Democratic base, and he was determined to avoid it, so that he could run up his own margin of victory.
Now, that should make the man blush.
There were a lot of predictable reactions to this shameless hypocrisy, but the most memorable came from the unlikeliest of sources: “Debilitating stupidity," former Republican leader Dick Armey called it on CNN. "Dimwitted."
But that’s voter suppression, and Chris Christie has fully embraced the method. And on Tuesday, he whined about his inability to exercise it.
Friday, August 22, 2014
Gov. Chris Christie's costly legal bills are mounting burden for N.J. taxpayers
By Times of Trenton
on August 22, 2014
The good people of New Jersey, already shelling out top dollar to keep their cash-strapped state running, have a new burden to carry: their governor’s legal bills.
The law firm representing Chris Christie and his administration in connection with the George Washington Bridge scandal has submitted its latest invoice — for a cool $6.5 million. Added to related government legal costs that We the People will be shouldering, the total comes to $8.5 million. And the meter is still running.
See anyone out there eager to dig into his pocket to dig Christie out of a hole many believe he dug for himself? Neither do we.
The recent bills came from the law firm of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher for an internal investigation which (surprise!) absolved the governor of wrongdoing in last fall’s incident, in which multiple lanes on the heavily trafficked bridge were inexplicably closed, causing massive gridlock.
This is hardly the first time the governor has shown a cavalier attitude toward taxpayers’ wallets. Remember that last year, he ordered a special election to replace the late U.S. Sen. Frank Lautenberg, just three weeks before a regularly scheduled November election.
His official reason? Christie didn’t want to cause “voter confusion.” The unofficial version? He didn’t care to share the ballot with the highly charismatic Cory Booker.
That thinking ran up an estimated tab of $12 million above and beyond the cost of a general election.
And then there are those town hall meetings — more than 120 so far — where the governor famously gets to insult teachers and call ex-Navy SEALS idiots. Billed as opportunities to interact with constituents, these gathering, often limited to a select audience, smell more to us like taxpayer-funded campaign rallies.
Meanwhile, costs for the legislative investigation into the bridge closings — closings many believe were meant as retaliation after Fort Lee Mayor Mark Sokolich, a Democrat, declined to endorse Christie — also continue to mount, even as federal authorities conduct their own probe.
By as early as April, the New Jersey Legislative Select Committee on Investigation, which Democratic lawmakers have used to get a handle on the bridge events, had spent at close to half a million in state funds for a legal team led by Reid Schar, a former federal prosecutor.
File under: Department of Redundancy Department.
The real tragedy is that all this money could have been so much more wisely spent — say, to restore the $7.5 million that under the Christie administration is no longer underwriting women’s health initiatives such as mammograms and cancer screenings.
on August 22, 2014
The good people of New Jersey, already shelling out top dollar to keep their cash-strapped state running, have a new burden to carry: their governor’s legal bills.
The law firm representing Chris Christie and his administration in connection with the George Washington Bridge scandal has submitted its latest invoice — for a cool $6.5 million. Added to related government legal costs that We the People will be shouldering, the total comes to $8.5 million. And the meter is still running.
See anyone out there eager to dig into his pocket to dig Christie out of a hole many believe he dug for himself? Neither do we.
The recent bills came from the law firm of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher for an internal investigation which (surprise!) absolved the governor of wrongdoing in last fall’s incident, in which multiple lanes on the heavily trafficked bridge were inexplicably closed, causing massive gridlock.
This is hardly the first time the governor has shown a cavalier attitude toward taxpayers’ wallets. Remember that last year, he ordered a special election to replace the late U.S. Sen. Frank Lautenberg, just three weeks before a regularly scheduled November election.
His official reason? Christie didn’t want to cause “voter confusion.” The unofficial version? He didn’t care to share the ballot with the highly charismatic Cory Booker.
That thinking ran up an estimated tab of $12 million above and beyond the cost of a general election.
And then there are those town hall meetings — more than 120 so far — where the governor famously gets to insult teachers and call ex-Navy SEALS idiots. Billed as opportunities to interact with constituents, these gathering, often limited to a select audience, smell more to us like taxpayer-funded campaign rallies.
Meanwhile, costs for the legislative investigation into the bridge closings — closings many believe were meant as retaliation after Fort Lee Mayor Mark Sokolich, a Democrat, declined to endorse Christie — also continue to mount, even as federal authorities conduct their own probe.
By as early as April, the New Jersey Legislative Select Committee on Investigation, which Democratic lawmakers have used to get a handle on the bridge events, had spent at close to half a million in state funds for a legal team led by Reid Schar, a former federal prosecutor.
File under: Department of Redundancy Department.
The real tragedy is that all this money could have been so much more wisely spent — say, to restore the $7.5 million that under the Christie administration is no longer underwriting women’s health initiatives such as mammograms and cancer screenings.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)